After her fiance is falsely imprisoned, a pregnant African-American woman sets out to clear his name and prove his innocence.
Will If Beale Street Could Talk make you cry?
If Beale Street Could Talk is sad in a slow, quiet way, and it is as likely to leave you angry as tearful. Barry Jenkins's adaptation of James Baldwin's novel follows Tish and Fonny, childhood friends who become a couple in 1970s New York. Tish is pregnant, and Fonny is in jail for a rape he did not commit.
Read the full write-up on If Beale Street Could Talk💧
No stories yet
Be the first to share how this movie made you feel.
How sad is If Beale Street Could Talk and will it make you cry?
If Beale Street Could Talk is sad in a slow, quiet way, and it is as likely to leave you angry as tearful. Barry Jenkins's adaptation of James Baldwin's novel follows Tish and Fonny, childhood friends who become a couple in 1970s New York. Tish is pregnant, and Fonny is in jail for a rape he did not commit.
The film moves back and forth between their courtship and the family's effort to get him out, so tenderness and injustice keep interrupting each other. Nothing is played for shock. The hurt comes from watching two families spend everything they have against a case that should never have been brought. It weighs most on anyone who has had a relative locked up. If you cry, it will probably be late in the film, and quietly.
Potential spoilers below
The following sections may reveal plot details.
Potential Soft Spots
- A partner, son or brother in prison
- Being pregnant while the father is locked up
- Wrongful arrest and racist policing
- Parents who close ranks around you when it counts
- In-laws who look down on you
- Visiting someone you love in jail
The Scenes That Get People
- Telling the families. Tish's parents and sister are worried but stand by her. Fonny's mother says Tish and the baby are damned, and Sharon answers that she has just condemned her own grandchild.
- The fathers at the bar. Frank frets about paying for a lawyer and a baby. Joseph tells him they will provide for this grandchild the way they provided for their own children.
- Puerto Rico. Sharon travels to find Victoria Rogers and asks her to change her testimony. Victoria refuses, and when Sharon gently touches her she screams until an elderly woman leads her away.
- The birth. Tish has their son, Alonzo Jr., without Fonny there.
- The visiting room. Fonny has accepted a plea deal. Tish and their son visit him in prison, share snacks and look ahead to his release.
Behind the Scenes & Cultural Impact
- It is adapted from James Baldwin's 1974 novel of the same name. Jenkins wrote the screenplay in 2013, four years before the project was announced. Wikipedia
- Regina King won the Academy Award and the Golden Globe for Best Supporting Actress as Sharon. The film was also Oscar-nominated for Best Adapted Screenplay and Best Original Score. Wikipedia
- It premiered at the Toronto International Film Festival in September 2018, and the National Board of Review and the American Film Institute both put it in their top ten films of the year. Wikipedia
Frequently Asked Questions
Is If Beale Street Could Talk sad?
Yes, in a restrained way. It is a love story told alongside a wrongful imprisonment, and the sadness comes from how little the families can do about it.
Does If Beale Street Could Talk have a happy ending?
Not a clean one. Fonny is not cleared: he takes a plea deal and is still in prison in the final scene. Tish and their son are visiting him, and the family is intact and waiting for his release.
Does Fonny get out of prison?
Not on screen. Victoria will not change her testimony, Fonny eventually accepts a plea deal, and the film ends with him still serving his sentence while Tish and their son visit.
Is If Beale Street Could Talk based on a true story?
No. It is adapted from James Baldwin's 1974 novel of the same name.
If Beale Street Could Talk is on these lists
More Sad Movies Like If Beale Street Could Talk
- Terms of Endearment (1983)💧5.0/5(1)
- La Bola Negra (2026)💧4.5/5(2)
- Fruitvale Station (2013)💧4.7/5(3)
- About Time (2013)💧3.6/5(11)
- All of Us Strangers (2023)💧4.3/5(6)
- Suggest a Movie








