Will Legends of the Fall make you cry?
Yes, and more than once, if old-fashioned melodrama works on you at all. Legends of the Fall follows the three Ludlow brothers, raised on a remote Montana ranch by a colonel who left the army in disgust at how the government treated Native Americans, and the woman who comes between them. It opens in 1914 and runs for decades.
Read the full write-up on Legends of the Fall💧
No stories yet
Be the first to share how this movie made you feel.
How sad is Legends of the Fall and will it make you cry?
Yes, and more than once, if old-fashioned melodrama works on you at all. Legends of the Fall follows the three Ludlow brothers, raised on a remote Montana ranch by a colonel who left the army in disgust at how the government treated Native Americans, and the woman who comes between them. It opens in 1914 and runs for decades.
The sadness is the sweeping, orchestral kind, set to a James Horner score. The first real blow comes early, in the First World War, and the film keeps handing out grief at intervals for the rest of its 133 minutes. Critics found it excessive and plenty of people cry anyway. It is hardest on viewers with brothers, and on anyone who has loved somebody who could not stay in one place.
Potential spoilers below
The following sections may reveal plot details.
Potential Soft Spots
- A brother who died young after you promised to keep him safe
- Loving someone who keeps leaving
- Being the dependable sibling who is never the favorite
- A parent silenced by a stroke
- Coming home from a war as a different person
- Waiting years for a letter
The Scenes That Get People
- Samuel. Tristan promised to protect his youngest brother and reaches him too late. He holds Samuel until he dies, then cuts out his heart so it can be sent home and buried at the ranch.
- The letter. Susannah has vowed to wait for Tristan while he travels the world. Years in, a letter arrives telling her to marry someone else.
- Isabel Two. Tristan has a wife and two children at last when a corrupt police officer working for the bootleggers kills her by accident.
- Susannah. Married to Alfred and still in love with Tristan, she visits him in jail and is turned away. Later she takes her own life.
- The bear. In 1963 Tristan, now an old man, meets a grizzly in the north country and draws his knife. One Stab, who narrates the film, calls it a good death.
Behind the Scenes & Cultural Impact
- It is based on Jim Harrison's 1979 novella of the same name. Wikipedia
- John Toll won the Academy Award for Best Cinematography, and the film was also nominated for art direction and sound. Wikipedia
- The Ludlow ranch was filmed in Alberta's Ghost River Wilderness Area, and the Helena street scenes in Vancouver's Gastown. Wikipedia
- It cost $30 million and grossed $160.6 million worldwide. Wikipedia
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Legends of the Fall sad?
Yes. It is a family saga in which the Ludlows lose someone in almost every act, from the First World War through Prohibition, and it is scored and shot to make each loss land.
Who dies in Legends of the Fall?
Samuel dies in the First World War, Tristan's wife Isabel Two is killed by a police officer, and Susannah takes her own life. Tristan himself dies as an old man in 1963, fighting a grizzly bear.
Is Legends of the Fall based on a true story?
No. It is adapted from a 1979 novella by Jim Harrison.
Legends of the Fall is on these lists
More Sad Movies Like Legends of the Fall
- Dear You (2026)💧4.0/5(2)
- Coco (2017)💧4.3/5(19)
- EO (2022)💧—/5
- Pig (2021)💧—/5
- Still Walking (2008)💧2.0/5(1)
- Saving Private Ryan (1998)💧4.3/5(3)
- Suggest a Movie








