Will My Sister's Keeper make you cry?
Very sad, and built to be. My Sister's Keeper is a hospital drama about Kate, a teenager with leukemia, and Anna, the younger sister her parents conceived through IVF to be her donor. When Anna is asked to give up a kidney at eleven, she hires a lawyer and sues her parents for control of her own body.
Read the full write-up on My Sister's Keeper💧
No stories yet
Be the first to share how this movie made you feel.
How sad is My Sister's Keeper and will it make you cry?
Very sad, and built to be. My Sister's Keeper is a hospital drama about Kate, a teenager with leukemia, and Anna, the younger sister her parents conceived through IVF to be her donor. When Anna is asked to give up a kidney at eleven, she hires a lawyer and sues her parents for control of her own body.
The crying starts early and comes in waves, because the film keeps cutting back to the years of treatment and what they cost each member of the family. It is open, unembarrassed melodrama, and critics were split on that. Parents take it hardest, along with anyone who grew up as the healthy sibling of a sick child. If you have read Jodi Picoult's novel, know that the film ends differently.
Potential spoilers below
The following sections may reveal plot details.
Potential Soft Spots
- A child or a sibling with cancer
- Growing up as the healthy kid in a family organized around a sick one
- Being the parent who cannot stop fighting
- Losing a first love young
- Being asked to let someone stop treatment
The Scenes That Get People
- Taylor. In flashback, Kate falls for Taylor, another cancer patient, and they go to a hospital prom for teenage patients. He dies soon after, and Kate takes an overdose of painkillers that Anna stops.
- The beach. Shortly before the hearing Kate asks for one last trip to the beach. Brian checks her out of the hospital for the day, and Sara only comes after he threatens divorce.
- The courtroom. Jesse cuts into Sara's cross-examination and gets Anna to admit the truth: Kate asked her to refuse. Kate knows she would not survive another operation and has had enough.
- The goodbye. Sara finally accepts that her daughter is ready to die. Kate dies in her sleep with her mother beside her.
Behind the Scenes & Cultural Impact
- In Jodi Picoult's 2004 novel, Anna wins the case, is killed in a car crash on the way home from court, and her kidney saves Kate. Picoult has said she regretted letting Nick Cassavetes direct because he changed the ending. Wikipedia
- Dakota and Elle Fanning were originally cast as Kate and Anna. Dakota dropped out after learning she would have to shave her head, and Elle left too. Wikipedia
- It cost $30 million and took $49.2 million in the US. Rotten Tomatoes has it at 47%, while CinemaScore audiences gave it an A-minus. Wikipedia
Frequently Asked Questions
Is My Sister's Keeper sad?
Yes, from start to finish. It is about a teenager with leukemia, the younger sister conceived to be her donor, and a family splitting over how far to go to keep her alive.
Does Kate die in My Sister's Keeper?
In the film, yes. Kate asks Anna to refuse the kidney donation because she is ready to stop, and she dies in her sleep with her mother beside her.
Is the ending of My Sister's Keeper different from the book?
Yes. In Jodi Picoult's novel Anna wins her case, dies in a car crash on the way home from court, and her kidney saves Kate. In the film Anna lives and Kate dies.
Is My Sister's Keeper based on a true story?
No. It is adapted from Jodi Picoult's 2004 novel of the same name.
My Sister's Keeper is on these lists
More Sad Movies Like My Sister's Keeper
- Dear You (2026)💧4.0/5(2)
- The Farewell (2019)💧1.0/5(2)
- The Land Before Time (1988)💧3.0/5(2)
- Riceboy Sleeps (2022)💧3.0/5(1)
- Atonement (2007)💧—/5
- Suggest a Movie








