A curmudgeonly instructor at a New England prep school is forced to remain on campus during Christmas break to babysit the handful of students with nowhere to go. Eventually, he forms an unlikely bond with one of them — a damaged, brainy troublemaker — and with the school’s head cook, who has just lost a son in Vietnam.
Will The Holdovers make you cry?
People usually don’t expect The Holdovers to make them cry because it feels warm and funny for most of its runtime. A lot of viewers describe laughing comfortably for a while — and then being caught off guard when the movie quietly reveals what the characters have been carrying the entire time.
Read the full write-up on The HoldoversWhat Others Are Saying
I didn’t expect to cry but the last scenes got me.
— Letterboxd review
Warm and heartbreaking at the same time.
— Reddit: r/movies
The conversations hit harder than anything dramatic.
— Letterboxd review
It feels like real life sadness.
— Reddit discussion
Left me emotional in a quiet way.
— Letterboxd review
How sad is The Holdovers (2023) and will it make you cry?
People usually don’t expect The Holdovers to make them cry because it feels warm and funny for most of its runtime. A lot of viewers describe laughing comfortably for a while — and then being caught off guard when the movie quietly reveals what the characters have been carrying the entire time.
The film spends time in small winter moments: meals, conversations, long walks, awkward silences. Because nothing is presented as dramatic, the emotional impact often arrives through understanding rather than plot. Viewers frequently say they grow attached before realizing the characters are all dealing with different kinds of loneliness.
Many reactions mention a gradual shift from cozy to reflective. Instead of a single heartbreaking scene, the movie lets sadness surface through honesty — characters admitting things they normally wouldn’t say out loud. The crying tends to happen late, often during conversations about family and loss rather than major events.
People often describe the emotion as comforting sadness — the kind where the movie hurts but also feels kind. Rather than devastation, viewers report feeling understood.
Potential spoilers below
The following sections may reveal plot details.
Potential Soft Spots
- Being alone during holidays
- Found family
- Teachers who care
- Grief that hides behind humor
- Teenagers needing guidance
- Adults pretending to be okay
What People Are Saying
"I didn’t expect to cry but the last scenes got me."
"Warm and heartbreaking at the same time."
"The conversations hit harder than anything dramatic."
"It feels like real life sadness."
"Left me emotional in a quiet way."
Behind the Scenes & Cultural Impact
- Many viewers compare the film to personal memories of school and teachers who shaped them.
- Discussions frequently focus on how humor makes the emotional moments more impactful.
- Audience reactions often describe the movie as comforting while still sad.
- The film gained a reputation online as a “gentle cry” rather than a devastating one.
The Holdovers is on these lists
More Sad Movies Like The Holdovers
- All the Bright Places (2020)💧3.8/5(4)
- All of Us Strangers (2023)💧4.3/5(6)
- Reign Over Me (2007)💧5.0/5(1)
- Moonlight (2016)💧3.5/5(2)
- Good Will Hunting (1997)💧3.6/5(5)
- Paddleton (2019)💧—/5
- Suggest a Movie








