Upon being sent to live with relatives in the countryside due to an illness, an emotionally distant adolescent girl becomes obsessed with an abandoned mansion and infatuated with a girl who lives there - a girl who may or may not be real.
Will When Marnie Was There make you cry?
When Marnie Was There is sad quietly for an hour and then all at once. This Studio Ghibli film follows Anna, a twelve-year-old foster child who dislikes herself and keeps everybody at arm's length. Sent to a seaside town in Hokkaido for the summer because of her asthma, she becomes fixed on an empty mansion across the salt marsh and on Marnie, the blonde girl who seems to live there and wants their friendship kept secret.
Read the full write-up on When Marnie Was There💧
No stories yet
Be the first to share how this movie made you feel.
How sad is When Marnie Was There and will it make you cry?
When Marnie Was There is sad quietly for an hour and then all at once. This Studio Ghibli film follows Anna, a twelve-year-old foster child who dislikes herself and keeps everybody at arm's length. Sent to a seaside town in Hokkaido for the summer because of her asthma, she becomes fixed on an empty mansion across the salt marsh and on Marnie, the blonde girl who seems to live there and wants their friendship kept secret.
For most of its length it plays as a gentle mystery with loneliness underneath. The crying comes in the last twenty minutes, when the film explains who Marnie is, and it comes fast. Adopted and fostered viewers take it hardest, along with anyone who grew up feeling like the odd one out in their own family. There is no villain and nothing frightening in it.
Potential spoilers below
The following sections may reveal plot details.
Potential Soft Spots
- Being adopted or fostered and wondering whether you were wanted
- Hating yourself at twelve
- A grandparent who raised you, or one you never got to know
- Parents who were always away
- Learning your family history late
- A friendship that lasted one summer
The Scenes That Get People
- The payments. Anna has found papers showing her foster parents receive government money for her care, and she has stopped believing they love her. Marnie answers with her own story of absent parents and a cruel nanny.
- The silo. Anna helps Marnie face the silo that terrifies her. In the storm Marnie starts calling her Kazuhiko, then vanishes, and Anna is sure she has been abandoned again.
- The apology. Anna confronts Marnie, who begs forgiveness and says they cannot meet again. Anna forgives her.
- Hisako's story. The painter who knew Marnie tells the rest: a husband who died suddenly, a daughter sent to boarding school who came home resentful, and a baby granddaughter Marnie took in after a car accident.
- The photograph. Anna finds Marnie's name on the back of an old picture of the mansion, understands that the baby was her, and accepts Yoriko as her mother.
Behind the Scenes & Cultural Impact
- It is adapted from Joan G. Robinson's 1967 novel, which Hayao Miyazaki had named as one of his favourite children's books. Producer Toshio Suzuki asked for the story to be moved to Japan. Wikipedia
- It was nominated for the Academy Award for Best Animated Feature. Wikipedia
- The closing song, Fine on the Outside, was written and performed by the American singer Priscilla Ahn. Wikipedia
Frequently Asked Questions
Is When Marnie Was There sad?
Yes. It is slow and gentle for most of its running time, then the last twenty minutes reveal a family history full of loss. Most of the crying happens there.
Who is Marnie in When Marnie Was There?
Marnie is Anna's grandmother. She raised Anna for a short time after Anna's parents died in a car accident, and Anna was later placed in foster care.
Does When Marnie Was There have a happy ending?
Yes. Anna learns where she comes from, forgives Marnie and accepts her foster mother Yoriko as her mother. As she leaves, she sees Marnie waving from the mansion window.
Is When Marnie Was There based on a book?
Yes, on the 1967 novel of the same name by Joan G. Robinson. The film moves the setting to Hokkaido in Japan.
When Marnie Was There is on these lists
More Sad Movies Like When Marnie Was There
- Ride Your Wave (2019)💧4.0/5(1)
- Pokémon: The First Movie (1998)💧1.0/5(1)
- A Silent Voice: The Movie (2016)💧5.0/5(1)
- Coco (2017)💧4.3/5(19)
- Suggest a Movie








