Will American History X make you cry?
For most of its two hours it is brutal more than sad, and then the final minutes change that. American History X stars Edward Norton as Derek Vinyard, a neo-Nazi gang leader in Los Angeles who comes out of prison a changed man and finds his younger brother Danny well down the road he laid out for him.
Read the full write-up on American History X💧
No stories yet
Be the first to share how this movie made you feel.
How sad is American History X and will it make you cry?
For most of its two hours it is brutal more than sad, and then the final minutes change that. American History X stars Edward Norton as Derek Vinyard, a neo-Nazi gang leader in Los Angeles who comes out of prison a changed man and finds his younger brother Danny well down the road he laid out for him.
Know what you are getting into. There is racist violence shown at close range and a rape in a prison shower. What it leaves behind is closer to dread and grief than to a good cry. It lands hardest on older siblings, and on anyone who has watched someone they love get drawn into hatred. If tears come, they come suddenly, right at the end.
Potential spoilers below
The following sections may reveal plot details.
Potential Soft Spots
- A younger sibling who copies everything you do
- A parent killed violently
- A family member pulled into a hate group
- Prejudice handed down from father to son
- Harm you did and cannot take back
The Scenes That Get People
- The dinner. A family meal with their mother's boyfriend Murray turns ugly. Derek assaults his sister Davina, insults Murray for being Jewish, and his mother throws him out.
- The curb. That same night Derek shoots a man who is stealing his truck, then stomps another on the curb while Danny watches.
- The laundry. In prison Derek is put to work beside Lamont, a Black inmate, and the two become friends. When Derek walks away from the Aryan Brotherhood he is beaten and raped, and it is Lamont who keeps him safe afterwards.
- The posters. Derek tells Danny what prison did to him, and the brothers take the Nazi posters down from their bedroom wall.
- The restroom. The next morning a Black student Danny had confronted the day before shoots him dead at school. Derek holds his body and blames himself while Danny's voice reads the end of his paper.
Behind the Scenes & Cultural Impact
- Director Tony Kaye disowned the film after New Line released a longer cut that Norton helped edit. He tried to have himself credited as "Humpty Dumpty" and filed a $200 million lawsuit that was dismissed in 2000. Wikipedia
- Norton took a pay cut of more than $500,000, put on about 25 pounds of muscle and was nominated for the Academy Award for Best Actor. Wikipedia
- It cost $20 million and grossed $23.9 million worldwide. Wikipedia
Frequently Asked Questions
Is American History X sad?
Yes, though it is violent and upsetting before it is sad. The sadness arrives with the ending, which is sudden and bleak.
Does Danny die in American History X?
Yes. Danny is shot dead in a school restroom by a Black student he had confronted the day before, the morning after he and Derek take down their Nazi posters.
Is American History X based on a true story?
No. Screenwriter David McKenna drew on his childhood in San Diego and his own observations of skinheads, but Derek and Danny Vinyard are fictional.
Why is part of American History X in black and white?
The flashbacks to Derek's years as a skinhead are in black and white. The present-day scenes are in color.
American History X is on these lists
More Sad Movies Like American History X
- Manchester by the Sea (2016)💧4.5/5(6)
- All of Us Strangers (2023)💧4.3/5(6)
- The Farewell (2019)💧1.0/5(2)
- Suggest a Movie








