After his older brother passes away, Lee Chandler is forced to return home to care for his 16-year-old nephew. There he is compelled to deal with a tragic past that separated him from his family and the community where he was born and raised.
Will Manchester by the Sea make you cry?
Many viewers reach for Manchester by the Sea when they want the kind of cry that’s heavy, quiet, and real — not a “sad montage,” more a slow weight that people describe as “draining.” If you’re searching will Manchester by the Sea make you cry or is Manchester by the Sea a tearjerker, the common answer is: a lot of people say yes… and some say it’s so raw they felt wiped out afterward.
Read the full write-up on Manchester by the SeaDear Manchester By the Sea Team, My parents lost their first-born daughter in a car accident 2 years before I was born. Though my parents stayed together after the accident, by no means was it a healthy or happy household for many years after losing my sister. From what I can piece together and the remnants I could see after I was born, there understandably was a lot of pent up sadness, anger, guilt, confusion and resentment between my parents. Despite knowing this, for many years I found it difficult to accept what seemed like my mom’s consistent depressive mood. In the same way, I think it may be difficult for many people to understand Affleck’s character. By the end of the movie there is a judgmental urge to think “How could he not take in his nephew???” By the end of the movie we’re all hoping for…more hope for him. But over the past few years and with some incredible grief resources (Check out the podcast “Losing a Child: Always Andy’s Mom“), I think I am finally accepting my mom for where she is and also accepting that I will (hopefully) never fully know how she feels. In “Always Andy’s Mom” it becomes so clear that losing a child is truly an unimaginable heartbreak. A grief counselor + thanatologist guest on the podcast even mentioned that in her grief center, the child grief support group is unique. It is the only group that mandates the facilitator to have personally experienced the same type of loss. This policy reflects the belief that understanding the grief of losing a child can only truly come from having gone through it oneself. This film helped me reach more acceptance of my mom and her feelings. And to challenge the urge to ask Lee to heal enough to take in his nephew. And I would say that for anyone that doesn’t understand Lee’s character at the end of the movie, to accept that. That, that is the point– you can’t understand. Appreciation for certain scenes: [Scene: When Lee and Randi unexpectedly run into each other on the street] This scene that truly broke me. When Randi says “I said a lot of terrible things to you… I said things that… I should fuckin’ burn in hell for what I said to you.” I couldn’t help but think of my dad and what he must have said to my mom after the accident. Though he was coming from a place of pain, I’m sure his words have left gushing wounds in my mom and her side of the family. Although I think my parents have mostly healed their relationship (it’s been over 30 years since the accident), I do hope one day he is able to apologize to my mom the way Randi does to Lee. [Scene: When Lee takes the gun from the police officers] Wow this scene left me with chills. I thought it was such a powerful portrayal of the overwhelming and surreal grief and guilt one feels when you can’t face reality. And apparently this feeling is very common for bereaved parents. Breaks my heart every time. I love you mom.
Dear Manchester By the Sea Team, My parents lost their first-born daughter in a car accident 2 years before I was born. Though my parents stayed together after the accident, by no means was it a healthy or happy household for many years after losing my sister. From what I can piece together and the remnants I could see after I was born, there understandably was a lot of pent up sadness, anger, gu...
What Others Are Saying
The way this movie temporarily destroyed my soul.
— Letterboxd — mathew
this film is so draining but i love it so much.
— Letterboxd — jwrite
kinda destroyed me tbh.
— Letterboxd — 03_riel
Being able to cry is almost a blessing… it’s the completely emptiness that’s the most crippling.
— Reddit — r/movies
I could barely get through that movie… Every time Michelle Williams spoke, I started audibly sobbing.
— The Ringer
How sad is Manchester by the Sea and will it make you cry?
Many viewers reach for Manchester by the Sea when they want the kind of cry that’s heavy, quiet, and real — not a “sad montage,” more a slow weight that people describe as “draining.” If you’re searching will Manchester by the Sea make you cry or is Manchester by the Sea a tearjerker, the common answer is: a lot of people say yes… and some say it’s so raw they felt wiped out afterward.
Reactions often mention crying midway and then getting hit again in the final stretch — with the emotion sometimes sticking around after it ends. You’ll see people describe it as “temporarily destroyed my soul” and talk about “audibly sobbing” in theaters. If you’re trying to cry during Manchester by the Sea, many viewers say it delivers — but it’s not a tidy, soothing release.
Potential spoilers below
The following sections may reveal plot details.
Potential Soft Spots
- Grief that doesn’t resolve neatly
- Guilt and self-blame
- Emotional numbness
- Family fractures
- Small-town memories that hurt
What People Are Saying
"The way this movie temporarily destroyed my soul."
"this film is so draining but i love it so much."
"kinda destroyed me tbh."
"Being able to cry is almost a blessing… it’s the completely emptiness that’s the most crippling."
"I could barely get through that movie… Every time Michelle Williams spoke, I started audibly sobbing."
Behind the Scenes & Cultural Impact
- Michelle Williams has said Kenneth Lonergan was crying behind the monitor during an emotional scene — “Keep going, keep going, keep going.” (Vulture)
- Entertainment Weekly similarly reported Williams saying you could hear Lonergan “weeping” behind the monitor. (Entertainment Weekly)
- The film’s editor Jennifer Lame has talked about living inside the sadness for months — and how the few lighter moments helped her get through cutting the toughest sequences. (MovieMaker)
- Michelle Williams has described the experience of making it as isolating and emotionally draining (long nights alone, commuting back and forth). (Vogue)
- It’s become a well-known “if you need a good cry” pick in culture writing — with people describing full-body sobbing in theaters. (The Ringer)
Manchester by the Sea is on these lists
More Sad Movies Like Manchester by the Sea
- The Farewell (2019)💧1.0/5(2)
- The Land Before Time (1988)💧3.0/5(2)
- Inside Out 2 (2024)💧3.5/5(10)
- Suggest a Movie








